AnyInfo.com

AnyInfo.com

Consumer Alert: Reliable Used Cars

New, used car prices, reviews and dealers Written By: MyRide.com
Reprinted under license.

J.D. Power & Associates says these are the most dependable vehicles

2005 Honda Civic
Continue to more photos from MyRide.com

Overview

Reliable Used Cars - News: Independent market research firm J.D. Power & Associates recently released the findings of its latest Vehicle Dependability Study, which measures problems experienced by 47,620 original owners of three-year-old vehicles. The top five brands in the 2006 study were, in order: Lexus, Mercury, Buick, Cadillac, and Toyota. Mini and Kia posted the most improvement in this year's study, though both still rank below the industry average. The least dependable brands in the study were, in order: Land Rover, Saab, Suzuki, Kia, and Hummer. See the top picks in 19 categories on the following pages.

 

Toyota Echo: Sub-compact Car

The Toyota Echo might not be pretty, but it sure satisfies its owners when it comes to dependability. If a reliable, inexpensive used car that gets great gas mileage is what you need, perhaps this funky Toyota can fill the bill. It was sold in coupe and sedan body styles.

Runners-up:
Hyundai Accent
Kia Rio Cinco

 

Honda Civic: Compact Car

Honda built its reputation for reliability on the strengths of the Honda Civic, so it's no surprise that it tops the compact car category. In 2003, the popular Civic was offered as a coupe, sedan, or sporty Si hatchback, in several levels of trim. Avoid Civics that have been modified (usually poorly) with aftermarket performance parts.

Runners-up:
Toyota Corolla
Toyota Prius

 

Buick Century: Midsize Car

Contrary to popular belief, it looks like General Motors and Ford build the most dependable midsize cars on the market. Buick's staid Century tops the list, followed by the nearly identical Buick Regal and the Mercury Sable. The Buicks are comfortable up front, a little tight in back, and nicely styled. Try to buy from an original owner - many Centurys are former rental cars.

Runners-up:
Buick Regal
Mercury Sable

 

Mercury Grand Marquis: Large Car

The Mercury Grand Marquis, beloved by many a retiree, is big inside, comfortable, and has a huge trunk. The engine and transmission are the same as those found in countless police cars and taxi cabs, and over the years this powertrain has stood the test of time. Many used examples have seen pampered lives in sunny, warm regions of the country. This Mercury makes for a good used car buy.

Runners-up:
Ford Crown Victoria
Buick Park Avenue

 

Mazda Miata: Compact Sporty Car

One of the purest expressions of a sports car on today's market, the Mazda Miata is terrific fun to drive, inexpensive to buy, and extremely dependable. It's a two-seater with a small trunk, but there's enough room for two on a weekend road trip. The top is easy to use, and Miatas get about 25 mpg combined. We highly recommend this car.

Runners-up:
Toyota MR2 Spyder
Toyota Celica

 

Chevrolet Monte Carlo: Midsize Sporty Car

We think J.D. Power & Associates stretches by calling the Chevrolet Monte Carlo a sporty car, since it drives more like a big coupe from the 1970s. The real surprise, however, is that the MC beat out the Toyota Solara and Honda Accord Coupe to win this category. When buying a Monte Carlo, try to find an original owner because many of these passed through rental fleets on their way to the used car marketplace.

Runners-up:
Toyota Solara
Ford Mustang

 

Honda S2000: Compact Premium Sporty Car

A world-class sports car in every way, the Honda S2000 is an acquired taste. To extract maximum performance, you've gotta be willing to rev the engine to maximum rpm, and that means many used S2000's have been wrung out on more than one occasion. Choose a low-mileage example from a mature owner or a certified-used S2000 that carries some protection from Honda. Avoid modified S2000s owned by people under 25 years of age.

Runners-up:
BMW Z4
Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class

 

Lexus SC 430: Premium Sporty Car

Despite its complex retractable hardtop, the Lexus SC 430 tops the consumer satisfaction rankings for sporty, high-end cars. Sensually shaped and exquisitely detailed, the Lexus SC 430 oozes sophistication and class, though it's not particularly fun to drive. If performance is your thing, try the runner-up in the category: the Chevrolet Corvette.

Runners-up:
Chevrolet Corvette
Ford Thunderbird

 

Acura CL: Entry Premium Car

Acura's entry-luxury CL coupe wins this category, but most people want a sedan. However, don't assume the nearly identical Acura TL four-door is the logical alternative. According to the J.D. Power data, the runners-up are the Infiniti I35 and the Lexus IS 300. If you prefer the sporty look of a coupe, the Acura CL satisfies, especially in performance-tuned Type-S trim.

Runners-up:
Infiniti I35
Lexus IS 300 and Lexus IS 300 SportCross

 

Lexus GS: Midsize Premium Car

Like any Lexus, the GS provides a sublime driving experience, top-notch interior materials, and comfortable seats. Each time you slide into the Lexus GS after a hard day at the office, you'll marvel at how simplicity, elegance, and luxury create a sanctuary from life's daily grind. It might not deliver the driving thrills of a BMW, but it almost makes the evening commute something to look forward to.

Runners-up:
Acura RL
Lexus ES 300

 

Lexus LS 430: Large Premium Car

When Lexus first debuted the LS 400 in 1990, German luxury automakers scoffed at the idea of a credible Japanese luxury sedan. They aren't laughing anymore. It seems Americans want a comfortable, dependable vehicle no matter how much money they're spending, and the Lexus LS 430 delivers. In fact, BMW and Benz aren't even in the top three for the category. Cadillac's DeVille and Lincoln's Town Car slot into second- and third-place.

Runners-up:
Cadillac DeVille
Lincoln Town Car

 

Toyota RAV4: Compact SUV

Toyota's RAV4 is one fun little ride. On dirt roads it drives like a rally car, and on pavement it combines responsive handling with good fuel economy. Big enough for four adults, the RAV4's space is spare, but the cargo area is deep and roomy. The main detriment is a tailgate that swings to the side, making it hard to load from the curb. (Photo shown is 2005 model.)

Runners-up:
Subaru Forester
Honda CR-V

 

Toyota Highlander: Midsize SUV

Pop quiz: Did you know that the Toyota Highlander is based on the Lexus RX 300? It's true, and the trickle-down theory of economics therefore dictates that quality emanates from each of the Highlander's pores. This is a roomy, comfortable, safe, and durable family vehicle that does just about everything well.

Runners-up:
Honda Pilot
Buick Rendezvous

 

GMC Yukon: Large SUV

ough consumer interest in big SUVs is waning due to fuel prices, some people still need a large, eight-passenger vehicle that can tow more than a pair of Jet Skis. When size matters, used car shoppers can turn to the GMC Yukon and GMC Yukon XL. They might not be refined, but their owners give them glowing reports for dependability.

Runners-up:
Chevrolet Suburban
Toyota Sequoia

 

Lexus GX 470: Midsize Premium SUV

Hold it right there. We recommend buying a Lexus GX 470 only if you plan to travel off-road, despite the fact that it wins this category. It's a beefy, ill-handling beast slathered in typical Lexus luxury and refinement that cannot hide its go-anywhere roots. If you're just tooling around town, try the Lexus RX 300 instead. It's a much better pavement pounder. And if you want something truly fun and functional, get the Infiniti FX.

Runners-up:
Lexus RX 300
Infiniti FX

 

Cadillac Escalade EXT: Large Premium SUV

See, this is why you can't trust automaker marketers. The Cadillac Escalade EXT is a pickup truck, plain and simple. That said, the Escalade EXT is one trick set of wheels. It can carry five adults and some stuff, or two adults and even more stuff thanks to its ingenious "midgate." If you want to save some cash, the Chevy Avalanche is the same thing without the fancy badge. Traditional SUV buyers will want to examine the Lexus LX 470.

Runners-up:
Lexus LX 470
Cadillac Escalade and Cadillac Escalade ESV

 

Honda Odyssey: Minivan

You can't go wrong with a used Honda Odyssey because it offers minivan buyers more than just durability. It's safe, it's comfortable, it's functional, and it's easy to use. Plus, for a minivan, it's even kinda stylish.

Runners-up:
Oldsmobile Silhouette
Pontiac Montana

 

Ford Ranger: Midsize Pickup

After 15 years on the market with minimal changes, the Ford Ranger had damn well better have the bugs all worked out. This ain't the most modern truck on the road, but many pickup buyers demand dependability over sophistication. Toyota's Tacoma is a good alternative, but we'd skip the Subaru Baja which is little more than an Outback station wagon with the roof sliced off.

Runners-up:
Subaru Baja
Toyota Tacoma

 

Toyota Tundra: Large Pickup

Though it proves durable, there are problems with the Toyota Tundra. It's a little bit smaller than the full-size trucks from Chevy, Dodge, Ford, and GMC. Its 4.7-liter V8 is less powerful than the top engines in other trucks, limiting the Tundra's towing capacity. Finally, in 2003, there wasn't a crew cab model available. If these aren't issues for you, then the Tundra makes a smart used truck buy.

Runners-up:
Ford F-150
Ford F-250 and Ford F-350

By: Christian Wardlaw
Photo credit: Photos courtesy of the automakers

 

Continue to Consumer Alert: Reliable Used Cars from MyRide.com

© 2008 Autobytel Inc. All rights reserved.



Privacy Policy | Copyright/Trademark Notification